STX E36 question
Moderator: Mike Simanyi
-
- Posts: 158
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:30 am
- Club: PSCC
- Car#: 61
STX E36 question
For those of you that know about the E36 I was wondering why the 325is is preferred over the later 328is.
I can't find any weight difference to speak of and the 328 has the ZF transmission that has proven more stout though that might be a source of extra weight. Your thoughts?
I can't find any weight difference to speak of and the 328 has the ZF transmission that has proven more stout though that might be a source of extra weight. Your thoughts?
- Jason Isley BS RX8
- Posts: 1129
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:26 am
- Car#: 0
- Location: Coto de Caza
- Contact:
Re: STX E36 question
Look at the actual gearing. The 325 has a slight edge which helps it get off of slow corners. When I drove both I found the 325 much more drivable, with the added tq of the 328 it was hard not to haze the rear tires.Morgan Trotter wrote:For those of you that know about the E36 I was wondering why the 325is is preferred over the later 328is.
I can't find any weight difference to speak of and the 328 has the ZF transmission that has proven more stout though that might be a source of extra weight. Your thoughts?
-
- Posts: 158
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:30 am
- Club: PSCC
- Car#: 61
Re: STX E36 question
325is final drive 3.15 328is final drive 2.93
- Marshall Grice
- Former CSCC Overall Champion
- Posts: 1617
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:27 am
- Club: CASOC
- Car#: 11
Re: STX E36 question
so wait, you're saying the smaller engine has shorter gearing which is a benefit because it doesn't have enough power and at the same time the bigger engine has too much power even though it has taller gearing and that is a negative?Jason Isley BS RX8 wrote:Look at the actual gearing. The 325 has a slight edge which helps it get off of slow corners. When I drove both I found the 325 much more drivable, with the added tq of the 328 it was hard not to haze the rear tires.Morgan Trotter wrote:For those of you that know about the E36 I was wondering why the 325is is preferred over the later 328is.
I can't find any weight difference to speak of and the 328 has the ZF transmission that has proven more stout though that might be a source of extra weight. Your thoughts?
- Jason Isley BS RX8
- Posts: 1129
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:26 am
- Car#: 0
- Location: Coto de Caza
- Contact:
Re: STX E36 question
I believe the trans ratios are also different.Morgan Trotter wrote:325is final drive 3.15 328is final drive 2.93
- Jason Isley BS RX8
- Posts: 1129
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:26 am
- Car#: 0
- Location: Coto de Caza
- Contact:
Re: STX E36 question
Yes. The 325 had the right balance of power and gearing, while the 328 just wanted to overpower the tires.Marshall Grice wrote:so wait, you're saying the smaller engine has shorter gearing which is a benefit because it doesn't have enough power and at the same time the bigger engine has too much power even though it has taller gearing and that is a negative?Jason Isley BS RX8 wrote:Look at the actual gearing. The 325 has a slight edge which helps it get off of slow corners. When I drove both I found the 325 much more drivable, with the added tq of the 328 it was hard not to haze the rear tires.Morgan Trotter wrote:For those of you that know about the E36 I was wondering why the 325is is preferred over the later 328is.
I can't find any weight difference to speak of and the 328 has the ZF transmission that has proven more stout though that might be a source of extra weight. Your thoughts?
-
- Posts: 158
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:30 am
- Club: PSCC
- Car#: 61
Re: STX E36 question
325is E36 Coupe Manual 1st 4.23, 2nd 2.52, 3rd 1.66, 4th 1.22, 5th 1.00, reverse 4.04, final drive 3.15, redline 6500
328is E36 Coupe Manual 1st 4.2, 2nd 2.49, 3rd 1.66, 4th 1.24, 5th 1.00, reverse 3.89, final drive 2.93, redline 6500
328is E36 Coupe Manual 1st 4.2, 2nd 2.49, 3rd 1.66, 4th 1.24, 5th 1.00, reverse 3.89, final drive 2.93, redline 6500
- Tom Berry
- Former CSCC Overall Champion
- Posts: 721
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:27 am
- Club: CASOC
- Car#: 72
- Location: Alta Loma, CA
Re: STX E36 question
You might want to re-check your weight info.
-
- Posts: 158
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:30 am
- Club: PSCC
- Car#: 61
Re: STX E36 question
yeah. its a little more of a weight difference that I had previously thought it was. Im finding that the coupe has a more ridgid chasis as well. Rumor had it that the weight was the same. I found the coupe to be 1 pound lighter. ha ha .
-
- Posts: 158
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:30 am
- Club: PSCC
- Car#: 61
Re: STX E36 question
to clairify, the 325 is quite a bit lighter. I dont know what I was thinking about before. I think i fould some wrong numbers.
- Steve Ekstrand
- Solo Safety Steward
- Posts: 7482
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:26 am
- Club: CASOC
- Car#: 15
- Location: This space left intentionally blank
- Contact:
Re: STX E36 question
Best friend had a 325is on a lease and was always traveling so never got to the mile limit... I'd, uhm... use his miles for him...
He replaced the 325is after two years with an absolutely identically equipped 328is. Even the same color and interior. Both manuals...
In nearly direct canyon comparisons I thought the 325is felt like it handled AND accelerated better. He was disappointed with the 328is because he assumed it would be better. I never got the overpower the tires sensation in the 328is.
He replaced the 325is after two years with an absolutely identically equipped 328is. Even the same color and interior. Both manuals...
In nearly direct canyon comparisons I thought the 325is felt like it handled AND accelerated better. He was disappointed with the 328is because he assumed it would be better. I never got the overpower the tires sensation in the 328is.
Dr. Conemangler
aka The Malefic One
2015 Wildcat Honda F600
aka The Malefic One
2015 Wildcat Honda F600
- Mark DeShon
- Posts: 473
- Joined: Mon Mar 09, 2009 8:57 pm
- Car#: 113
Re: STX E36 question
I've been pondering this same question lately. The 328s are heavier, but not by as much as some people make it seem. And if Derek Punch isn't playing games with me, he's pushing 40 more hp than the most powerful STX 325s in the country(pretty impressive for 300 extra CCs). Having ridden shotgun in his car once, I tend to believe it. I would have to do more research in regards to whether the power is in the right place, but it's something I am planning to look into. However, keep in mind. Horsepower helps you in a strait line. Light weight helps you everywhere.Morgan Trotter wrote:For those of you that know about the E36 I was wondering why the 325is is preferred over the later 328is.
I can't find any weight difference to speak of and the 328 has the ZF transmission that has proven more stout though that might be a source of extra weight. Your thoughts?
Mark D.
- Mark DeShon
- Posts: 473
- Joined: Mon Mar 09, 2009 8:57 pm
- Car#: 113
Re: STX E36 question
Jason Isley BS RX8 wrote: ...with the added tq of the 328 it was hard not to haze the rear tires.
- Eric Clements
- Solo Safety Steward
- Posts: 895
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:25 am
- Club: No$
- Car#: 30
- Location: Pasadena
Re: STX E36 question
I was told the added B pillar made the sedan stiffer...Morgan Trotter wrote: Im finding that the coupe has a more ridgid chasis as well.
-
- Posts: 158
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:30 am
- Club: PSCC
- Car#: 61
Re: STX E36 question
Eric, that's what I previously read but found some other much older data. Who know what to believe?
- Jason Isley BS RX8
- Posts: 1129
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:26 am
- Car#: 0
- Location: Coto de Caza
- Contact:
Re: STX E36 question
Having driven Derek's car I found it much more difficult to drive than the 325 in STX trim, it was easy to overpower the tires on corner exit, where the 325 just trucked along smoothly. I find drive-ability much more important than overall speed in an event where you only get three runs.Mark DeShon wrote:
I've been pondering this same question lately. The 328s are heavier, but not by as much as some people make it seem. And if Derek Punch isn't playing games with me, he's pushing 40 more hp than the most powerful STX 325s in the country(pretty impressive for 300 extra CCs). Having ridden shotgun in his car once, I tend to believe it. I would have to do more research in regards to whether the power is in the right place, but it's something I am planning to look into. However, keep in mind. Horsepower helps you in a strait line. Light weight helps you everywhere.
Mark D.
Its not unlike the L98/LT1/LT4 C4 Corvettes, they all make great power, but differently, and gives an edge to certain combinations.
-
- Posts: 89
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:26 am
Re: STX E36 question
Jason, I'd say that's a tuning issue. A *properly* working diff (and suspension setup) should allow you to put the 328's power advantage to use.
-Signed Mr. I really want to build a 350z for STR
-Signed Mr. I really want to build a 350z for STR
- Marshall Grice
- Former CSCC Overall Champion
- Posts: 1617
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:27 am
- Club: CASOC
- Car#: 11
Re: STX E36 question
I think it's tough to make a blanket statement about the engines like that without considering any other factors, namely rear alignment and lateral load transfer distribution. It's very possible that Derek likes his car setup that way and who ever owned the 325 didn't.Jason Isley BS RX8 wrote: Having driven Derek's car I found it much more difficult to drive than the 325 in STX trim, it was easy to overpower the tires on corner exit, where the 325 just trucked along smoothly. I find drive-ability much more important than overall speed in an event where you only get three runs.
Its not unlike the L98/LT1/LT4 C4 Corvettes, they all make great power, but differently, and gives an edge to certain combinations.
- Jason Isley BS RX8
- Posts: 1129
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:26 am
- Car#: 0
- Location: Coto de Caza
- Contact:
Re: STX E36 question
Setup would certainly always be a consideration. But the question was a pretty general why is the 325 preferred over the 328, this was my opinion from having driven examples of both.Marshall Grice wrote: I think it's tough to make a blanket statement about the engines like that without considering any other factors, namely rear alignment and lateral load transfer distribution. It's very possible that Derek likes his car setup that way and who ever owned the 325 didn't.
- Jason Isley BS RX8
- Posts: 1129
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:26 am
- Car#: 0
- Location: Coto de Caza
- Contact:
Re: STX E36 question
That is possible... But gearing and weight could overcome that tq advantage, and judging by the results of the two cars that is often the case.Brian Peters wrote:Jason, I'd say that's a tuning issue. A *properly* working diff (and suspension setup) should allow you to put the 328's power advantage to use.
-Signed Mr. I really want to build a 350z for STR
- Will Kalman
- Posts: 1210
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:24 am
- Club: PSCC
- Car#: 232
Re: STX E36 question
If only there were some type of "throttling" device that would allow you to reduce the power output when necessary while still allowing greater power to be delivered when it could be applied..... Maybe actuated through a "skill" type interface.... }:)Jason Isley BS RX8 wrote: it was easy to overpower the tires on corner exit, where the 325 just trucked along smoothly.
- John Coffey
- Posts: 635
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:24 am
- Club: PSCC
- Car#: 250
- Location: La Habra, CA
- Contact:
Re: STX E36 question
My vote for the best motorsports board post of the year!If only there were some type of "throttling" device that would allow you to reduce the power output when necessary while still allowing greater power to be delivered when it could be applied..... Maybe actuated through a "skill" type interface...
- Marshall Grice
- Former CSCC Overall Champion
- Posts: 1617
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:27 am
- Club: CASOC
- Car#: 11
Re: STX E36 question
LOLWill Kalman wrote:If only there were some type of "throttling" device that would allow you to reduce the power output when necessary while still allowing greater power to be delivered when it could be applied..... Maybe actuated through a "skill" type interface.... }:)Jason Isley BS RX8 wrote: it was easy to overpower the tires on corner exit, where the 325 just trucked along smoothly.
I wasn't ballzy enough to go there.
- Jason Isley BS RX8
- Posts: 1129
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:26 am
- Car#: 0
- Location: Coto de Caza
- Contact:
Re: STX E36 question
If only. Perhaps you and Marshall will finally figure out how to make yours work this year. ;)Will Kalman wrote:If only there were some type of "throttling" device that would allow you to reduce the power output when necessary while still allowing greater power to be delivered when it could be applied..... Maybe actuated through a "skill" type interface.... }:)Jason Isley BS RX8 wrote: it was easy to overpower the tires on corner exit, where the 325 just trucked along smoothly.
-
- Posts: 158
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:30 am
- Club: PSCC
- Car#: 61
Re: STX E36 question
That stings