Air Filter
Moderator: Mike Simanyi
Air Filter
I'm going to be changing my air filter to a non-OEM model shortly (been on bumper-to-bumper care until now). I'm strongly considering a K&N reusable filter, but I noticed that it requires oil after cleaning. After doing some research, it looks like most aftermarket performance filters use oil as well. I've heard that the oil can make it's way into the intake and get into the valves/cylinders and cause carbon buildup. If that's the case, it'd be even more of a problem for me, since my engine is direct injection and you can't use gas-bourne detergents to clean the valves. Anyone have any insights? Is this just a nasty rumor?
==============
Oversteer is better than understeer because you don't see the tree you're hitting.
Oversteer is better than understeer because you don't see the tree you're hitting.
- Mako Koiwai
- Posts: 6490
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:25 am
- Club: SCNAX
- Car#: 34
- Location: South Pasadena, CA
- Contact:
Re: Air Filter
One must be very judicious adding the oil. It's easy to over do it, but since it's dyed red, it's easy to use. After you clean the filter with their cleaner and let it dry, it will be white. You put a little of the oil on and let it spread out. You can see if there is any white left and add a tiny bit more where needed.
You would have to put an awful lot on to create the "damage" that you mention. The first thing that can be effected by oil coming off of the filter is the mass air flow metering element. There is a spray that you can buy to blast it clean if necessary.
You would have to put an awful lot on to create the "damage" that you mention. The first thing that can be effected by oil coming off of the filter is the mass air flow metering element. There is a spray that you can buy to blast it clean if necessary.
- John Stimson
- Posts: 486
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:27 am
- Club: PSCC
- Car#: 124
Re: Air Filter
I have two things for you to consider:
1) OE type paper filters don't present much of a restriction.
2) K&N type oiled fiber filters don't filter as well as paper.
1) OE type paper filters don't present much of a restriction.
2) K&N type oiled fiber filters don't filter as well as paper.
Re: Air Filter
Good info. Thanks, John.John Stimson wrote:I have two things for you to consider:
1) OE type paper filters don't present much of a restriction.
2) K&N type oiled fiber filters don't filter as well as paper.
==============
Oversteer is better than understeer because you don't see the tree you're hitting.
Oversteer is better than understeer because you don't see the tree you're hitting.
- Jason Isley BS RX8
- Posts: 1129
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:26 am
- Car#: 0
- Location: Coto de Caza
- Contact:
Re: Air Filter
Yeah oiled filters suck. He should run two paper filters for extra protection. }:)John Stimson wrote:I have two things for you to consider:
1) OE type paper filters don't present much of a restriction.
2) K&N type oiled fiber filters don't filter as well as paper.
Cant find the PDF, but we tested these back-to-back-to-back on the dyno (same day, multiple runs, with repeats) in our RX-8.
A dirty K&N, full season of use made the least power. We would have liked to clean and retest it, but it could not be done in the confines of the time allotted, which is why we brought a brand new one as well.
Brand new out of the box Mazda (OE paper) filter made 2hp (peak) more than the dirty K&N, with the same Tq.
Brand new out of the box K&N made 5hp and 2tq more than the dirty K&N.
Brand new out of the box Green filter made 7hp and 2tq more than the dirty K&N.
These numbers are on a dynojet, at the wheels.
Call C2 and order a Green.
- Bobby Beyer
- Posts: 356
- Joined: Wed Nov 30, 2011 5:52 pm
Re: Air Filter
Kurt Rahn wrote:I'm going to be changing my air filter to a non-OEM model shortly (been on bumper-to-bumper care until now). I'm strongly considering a K&N reusable filter, but I noticed that it requires oil after cleaning. After doing some research, it looks like most aftermarket performance filters use oil as well. I've heard that the oil can make it's way into the intake and get into the valves/cylinders and cause carbon buildup. If that's the case, it'd be even more of a problem for me, since my engine is direct injection and you can't use gas-bourne detergents to clean the valves. Anyone have any insights? Is this just a nasty rumor?
Its not that it'll make its way into the engine but that it'll contaminate the MAF sensor and mess up the readings or cause CEL. Look around on the Mustang and Camaro forums its apparently a problem when to much oil is reapplied when cleaning, I never had an issue but I followed the instructions pretty well.
FWIW I made 5 more hp in my Mustang going to a K&N, never tried a green, but I've head they don't filter very well so more frequent oil changes will probably be required.
Last edited by Bobby Beyer on Fri Nov 16, 2012 1:59 pm, edited 2 times in total.
"Promise mediocrity. Deliver just slightly better." - Jarrett Bellini
- Jason Isley BS RX8
- Posts: 1129
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:26 am
- Car#: 0
- Location: Coto de Caza
- Contact:
Re: Air Filter
If there is oil dripping off of the filter after you service it you may have used to much. I always clean the MAF when I am servicing the filter. Never had a CEL light from a filter change, and had lots of trouble free miles on our RX-8 with the Green installed. I cant think of a car I have owned that did not have a K&N or Green filter installed - including our 2001 Expedition that has had one of these types of filters installed for about 190,000 of its 204,000 mile life so far.
- Davin Swanson
- Posts: 195
- Joined: Sun Aug 14, 2011 8:09 pm
- Club: CASOC
- Car#: 979
Re: Air Filter
Kurt, your turbo will push as much air as the engine is asking for under normal conditions. The HP gains that people are reporting with NA engines will equate to maybe quicker spool times under initial throttle. How much quicker? Probably not very much.
IMO, stay with paper. Just make sure to change it often enough. The other thing extra restriction does is push your turbo higher on the compressor map, which at full power will mean less efficiency and a hotter charge.
IMO, stay with paper. Just make sure to change it often enough. The other thing extra restriction does is push your turbo higher on the compressor map, which at full power will mean less efficiency and a hotter charge.
Re: Air Filter
I knew it, I knew it. You've been cheating in SK2! Come on Big Boy, where you hiding that turbo...under your seat?Davin Swanson wrote:Kurt, your turbo will push as much air as the engine is asking for under normal conditions. The HP gains that people are reporting with NA engines will equate to maybe quicker spool times under initial throttle. How much quicker? Probably not very much.
IMO, stay with paper. Just make sure to change it often enough. The other thing extra restriction does is push your turbo higher on the compressor map, which at full power will mean less efficiency and a hotter charge.
2012 ES Regional Champion
2001 NB Miata
2001 NB Miata
- Davin Swanson
- Posts: 195
- Joined: Sun Aug 14, 2011 8:09 pm
- Club: CASOC
- Car#: 979
Re: Air Filter
It's all residual knowledge from my days of turbo diesel VWs. I swear!Ed Holley wrote:I knew it, I knew it. You've been cheating in SK2! Come on Big Boy, where you hiding that turbo...under your seat?Davin Swanson wrote:Kurt, your turbo will push as much air as the engine is asking for under normal conditions. The HP gains that people are reporting with NA engines will equate to maybe quicker spool times under initial throttle. How much quicker? Probably not very much.
IMO, stay with paper. Just make sure to change it often enough. The other thing extra restriction does is push your turbo higher on the compressor map, which at full power will mean less efficiency and a hotter charge.
Re: Air Filter
That's what I'm talkin' 'bout! Thanks, Jason!Jason Isley BS RX8 wrote:Yeah oiled filters suck. He should run two paper filters for extra protection. }:)John Stimson wrote:I have two things for you to consider:
1) OE type paper filters don't present much of a restriction.
2) K&N type oiled fiber filters don't filter as well as paper.
Cant find the PDF, but we tested these back-to-back-to-back on the dyno (same day, multiple runs, with repeats) in our RX-8.
A dirty K&N, full season of use made the least power. We would have liked to clean and retest it, but it could not be done in the confines of the time allotted, which is why we brought a brand new one as well.
Brand new out of the box Mazda (OE paper) filter made 2hp (peak) more than the dirty K&N, with the same Tq.
Brand new out of the box K&N made 5hp and 2tq more than the dirty K&N.
Brand new out of the box Green filter made 7hp and 2tq more than the dirty K&N.
These numbers are on a dynojet, at the wheels.
Call C2 and order a Green.
==============
Oversteer is better than understeer because you don't see the tree you're hitting.
Oversteer is better than understeer because you don't see the tree you're hitting.
- Richard Jung
- Posts: 448
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:24 am
- Club: PSCC
- Car#: 71
- Location: Irvine, CA
- Contact:
Re: Air Filter
+1Jason Isley BS RX8 wrote:Yeah oiled filters suck. He should run two paper filters for extra protection. }:)John Stimson wrote:I have two things for you to consider:
1) OE type paper filters don't present much of a restriction.
2) K&N type oiled fiber filters don't filter as well as paper.
Cant find the PDF, but we tested these back-to-back-to-back on the dyno (same day, multiple runs, with repeats) in our RX-8.
A dirty K&N, full season of use made the least power. We would have liked to clean and retest it, but it could not be done in the confines of the time allotted, which is why we brought a brand new one as well.
Brand new out of the box Mazda (OE paper) filter made 2hp (peak) more than the dirty K&N, with the same Tq.
Brand new out of the box K&N made 5hp and 2tq more than the dirty K&N.
Brand new out of the box Green filter made 7hp and 2tq more than the dirty K&N.
These numbers are on a dynojet, at the wheels.
Call C2 and order a Green.
After Jason did that testing, I saw a demo at SEMA where the Green Filter out flowed K&N. Better flow may = less filtering, but I've been running a Green Filter ever since.
- Marshall Grice
- Former CSCC Overall Champion
- Posts: 1617
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:27 am
- Club: CASOC
- Car#: 11
Re: Air Filter
...how much more front wheel spin are you looking for Kurt?
- KJ Christopher
- Executive Board Member
- Posts: 2818
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:29 am
- Club: No$
- Car#: 11
- Location: Redondo Beach, CA
Re: Air Filter
Marshall Grice wrote:...how much more front wheel spin are you looking for Kurt?
kj
Use the email link. I don't read nor get notified of PMs.
Former No$ Club Rep | Former SCCA Area 11 Director |Former CSCC Solo Chair
Caged Z Motorsports - automotive consultation
The ACME Special Now with Super Speed Vitamins
Use the email link. I don't read nor get notified of PMs.
Former No$ Club Rep | Former SCCA Area 11 Director |Former CSCC Solo Chair
Caged Z Motorsports - automotive consultation
The ACME Special Now with Super Speed Vitamins
Re: Air Filter
Sadly, it looks like Green doesn't offer a filter for the Mini. K&N it is...Richard Jung wrote:+1Jason Isley BS RX8 wrote:Call C2 and order a Green.
After Jason did that testing, I saw a demo at SEMA where the Green Filter out flowed K&N. Better flow may = less filtering, but I've been running a Green Filter ever since.
==============
Oversteer is better than understeer because you don't see the tree you're hitting.
Oversteer is better than understeer because you don't see the tree you're hitting.
Re: Air Filter
What can I say? I like tire smoke!Marshall Grice wrote:...how much more front wheel spin are you looking for Kurt?
==============
Oversteer is better than understeer because you don't see the tree you're hitting.
Oversteer is better than understeer because you don't see the tree you're hitting.