Drones at events
Moderator: Mike Simanyi
- Mike Simanyi
- Former Club Chair
- Posts: 2460
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:26 am
- Club: No$
- Car#: 6
Drones at events
There are several inexpensive drones available on the market now, and I believe we've even seen drone footage at one of our own events.
As cool as it was to see that, the SCCA now has an official position and it effectively means we can't have drones at events.
The only way they are allowed is if (1) the drone operator has FAA certification to operate the drone and (b) if the drone operator provides insurance for $10,000,000 liability, specifically including unmanned aircraft systems (UAS) coverage, naming the SCCA and the usual list of additional insureds (which varies by venue for us.)
Sorry to be the buzz kill on this.
Mike
As cool as it was to see that, the SCCA now has an official position and it effectively means we can't have drones at events.
The only way they are allowed is if (1) the drone operator has FAA certification to operate the drone and (b) if the drone operator provides insurance for $10,000,000 liability, specifically including unmanned aircraft systems (UAS) coverage, naming the SCCA and the usual list of additional insureds (which varies by venue for us.)
Sorry to be the buzz kill on this.
Mike
- Jayson Woodruff
- Posts: 1754
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:26 am
- Club: PSCC
- Car#: 51
Re: Drones at events
How is Amazon going to deliver my spark plugs to the event now?
Jay W
Jay W
- Bill Martin
- Posts: 537
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:26 am
- Club: GRA
- Car#: 74
Re: Drones at events
How ironic:
"drone(n): A drone is someone who follows an ideology or some other form of idealization blindly and uncritically."
BTW, according to the FAA the quads you've seen are not legally classed as "drones". I own several not-drones. Don't take them to events however, so don't hit me Boss.
"drone(n): A drone is someone who follows an ideology or some other form of idealization blindly and uncritically."
BTW, according to the FAA the quads you've seen are not legally classed as "drones". I own several not-drones. Don't take them to events however, so don't hit me Boss.
Re: Drones at events
If the SCCA, or even SoCal Solo wants to outlaw them, they should just say "not allowed". Period.Mike Simanyi wrote:The only way they are allowed is if (1) the drone operator has FAA certification to operate the drone and...
Mike
But relating to FAA, there is no certification possible or required by the FAA. They are totally legal for "recreational" purposes, as long as flown below 400 feet, and sufficiently away from populated areas and full scale aircraft.
2012 ES Regional Champion
2001 NB Miata
2001 NB Miata
- Marshall Grice
- Former CSCC Overall Champion
- Posts: 1617
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:27 am
- Club: CASOC
- Car#: 11
Re: Drones at events
skateboards are also completely legal, and completely banned from SCCA solo.
the allowance for FAA certification is for commercial purposes for which there is a process to license.
the allowance for FAA certification is for commercial purposes for which there is a process to license.
- Steve Ekstrand
- Solo Safety Steward
- Posts: 7482
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:26 am
- Club: CASOC
- Car#: 15
- Location: This space left intentionally blank
- Contact:
Re: Drones at events
I've seen several peer-reviewed law articles from major journals discussing the confusion and contradictions within FAA regulations over all uses of drones and drone like things. If the best legal minds in the country can't come to clear agreement on the state of regulation and process then I think the comments I've read above are not as authoritative as their author's believe.
Dr. Conemangler
aka The Malefic One
2015 Wildcat Honda F600
aka The Malefic One
2015 Wildcat Honda F600
- Q V
- Solo Safety Steward
- Posts: 1398
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:26 am
- Club: SCNAX
- Car#: 69
- Location: Orange County, CA
Re: Drones at events
I think at least that ban is gone now... I think. The verbiage banning skateboards/razors/etc. is no longer in the SCCA rule book last time I checked.Marshall Grice wrote:skateboards are also completely legal, and completely banned from SCCA solo.
So, although we can't fly drones... we can fly our non-drones?
- Craig Naylor
- Posts: 1973
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:30 am
- Club: SCNAX
- Car#: 80
- Location: Long Beach
Re: Drones at events
How about directly off of the FAA website: http://www.faa.gov/about/initiatives/uas/uas_faq/Steve Ekstrand wrote:I've seen several peer-reviewed law articles from major journals discussing the confusion and contradictions within FAA regulations over all uses of drones and drone like things. If the best legal minds in the country can't come to clear agreement on the state of regulation and process then I think the comments I've read above are not as authoritative as their author's believe.
Do I need to get approval from the FAA to fly a model aircraft for recreation?
No. FAA guidance does not address size of the model aircraft. FAA guidance says that model aircraft flights should be kept below 400 feet above ground level (AGL), should be flown a sufficient distance from populated areas and full scale aircraft, and are not for business purposes. 1, 2
More specifically here is the section of federal law exempting from licensing, and outlining what can be done with model aircraft.
SEC. 336. SPECIAL RULE FOR MODEL AIRCRAFT.
(a) IN GENERAL.—Notwithstanding any other provision of law
relating to the incorporation of unmanned aircraft systems into
Federal Aviation Administration plans and policies, including this
subtitle, the Administrator of the Federal Aviation Administration
may not promulgate any rule or regulation regarding a model
aircraft, or an aircraft being developed as a model aircraft, if—
(1) the aircraft is flown strictly for hobby or recreational
use;
(2) the aircraft is operated in accordance with a communitybased
set of safety guidelines and within the programming
of a nationwide community-based organization;
(3) the aircraft is limited to not more than 55 pounds
unless otherwise certified through a design, construction,
inspection, flight test, and operational safety program administered
by a community-based organization;
(4) the aircraft is operated in a manner that does not
interfere with and gives way to any manned aircraft; and
(5) when flown within 5 miles of an airport, the operator
of the aircraft provides the airport operator and the airport
air traffic control tower (when an air traffic facility is located
at the airport) with prior notice of the operation (model aircraft
operators flying from a permanent location within 5 miles of
an airport should establish a mutually-agreed upon operating
procedure with the airport operator and the airport air traffic
control tower (when an air traffic facility is located at the
airport)).
(b) STATUTORY CONSTRUCTION.—Nothing in this section shall
be construed to limit the authority of the Administrator to pursue
enforcement action against persons operating model aircraft who
endanger the safety of the national airspace system.
(c) MODEL AIRCRAFT DEFINED.—In this section, the term ‘‘model
aircraft’’ means an unmanned aircraft that is—
(1) capable of sustained flight in the atmosphere;
(2) flown within visual line of sight of the person operating
the aircraft; and
(3) flown for hobby or recreational purposes.
So the "drones" as you labeled them are technically UA's, and all of them I've seen to date at an event unless owned and operated for commercial purposes (vs. hobbies) are legal to be flown. What jurisdiction does the SCCA have to outlaw them? Site locations maybe...but not the SCCA.
Last edited by Craig Naylor on Wed May 28, 2014 8:50 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- Bill Martin
- Posts: 537
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:26 am
- Club: GRA
- Car#: 74
Re: Drones at events
I would think an event site would be considered a populated area.
- Craig Naylor
- Posts: 1973
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:30 am
- Club: SCNAX
- Car#: 80
- Location: Long Beach
Re: Drones at events
Never was in the rule book, used to be in Tour/Pro/Nats supplements. I believe it came about because of poor pavement issues in Topeka. Disappeared from the sups a year or two after the site was dropped. Skateboard remained longer... can't recall if they are still listed or not...know the razor limit went away years ago, that's why I carry one now. Fits in a Miata trunk, where a bike does not.Quoc-Viet Dang wrote:The verbiage banning skateboards/razors/etc. is no longer in the SCCA rule book last time I checked.
- Craig Naylor
- Posts: 1973
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:30 am
- Club: SCNAX
- Car#: 80
- Location: Long Beach
Re: Drones at events
Define populated.... I've seen 50+ people at El Toro down at the Model Aircraft zone on a Saturday. I've been to a model aircraft competition with several hundred people in attendance.Bill Martin wrote:I would think an event site would be considered a populated area.
- KJ Christopher
- Executive Board Member
- Posts: 2818
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:29 am
- Club: No$
- Car#: 11
- Location: Redondo Beach, CA
Re: Drones at events
They provide our sanction, so that gives them jurisdiction.Craig Naylor wrote:So the "drones" as you labeled them are technically UA's, and all of them I've seen to date at an event unless owned and operated for commercial purposes (vs. hobbies) are legal to be flown. What jurisdiction does the SCCA have to outlaw them? Site locations maybe...but not the SCCA.
But I suspect the answer you're really after is: When the insurance company notifies the SCCA that coverage doesn't extend to UAs.
kj
Use the email link. I don't read nor get notified of PMs.
Former No$ Club Rep | Former SCCA Area 11 Director |Former CSCC Solo Chair
Caged Z Motorsports - automotive consultation
The ACME Special Now with Super Speed Vitamins
Use the email link. I don't read nor get notified of PMs.
Former No$ Club Rep | Former SCCA Area 11 Director |Former CSCC Solo Chair
Caged Z Motorsports - automotive consultation
The ACME Special Now with Super Speed Vitamins
- Craig Naylor
- Posts: 1973
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:30 am
- Club: SCNAX
- Car#: 80
- Location: Long Beach
Re: Drones at events
Your missing my point. We'll start with I don't own one... and I'm playing devil's advocate here... If I did and chose to fly one at an event... what are you going to do grab the controls from me and crash it? Sure you could ask me to leave... so one steps outside the wristband boundary point and flys from there. The side steps are boundless. It's an unenforceable mandate of a mute issue...as a NTSB Administrative Law Judge has actually written judgment against the FAA with prejudice saying the FAA has no jurisdiction over any model airplane issue even if for commercial usage.KJ Christopher wrote:They provide our sanction, so that gives them jurisdiction.Craig Naylor wrote:So the "drones" as you labeled them are technically UA's, and all of them I've seen to date at an event unless owned and operated for commercial purposes (vs. hobbies) are legal to be flown. What jurisdiction does the SCCA have to outlaw them? Site locations maybe...but not the SCCA.
But I suspect the answer you're really after is: When the insurance company notifies the SCCA that coverage doesn't extend to UAs.
http://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q= ... 0277,d.cWc
So... just thinking out loud here...if the NTSB has determined the FAA does not have jurisdiction over model airplanes... what standing do you think they might find for a Sports Car Club over model airplanes?
Re: Drones at events
In a way, drones, UAs, etc. are in our future (present). Having said that, and fully realizing that Mike is just the messenger, this is clearly a safety issue. The SCCA should not be simply kicking the can down the road toward the FAA. It clearly is NOT the FAA's jurisdiction. But I agree with KJ, it IS the SCCA's jurisdiction. They should attack this issue from the point of view that, at best, it's a distraction at a motorsports event, and at worst, it's a safety hazard to course workers and driver's, not to mention the possibility of property damage leading to an insurable or NON-insurable event.
2012 ES Regional Champion
2001 NB Miata
2001 NB Miata
- Marshall Grice
- Former CSCC Overall Champion
- Posts: 1617
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:27 am
- Club: CASOC
- Car#: 11
Re: Drones at events
WTF? the SCCA isn't going to arrest you for flying a quadcopter. They (we?) will do exactly what they would do in any other situation where they are operating outside of their liability insurance coverage, stop the event.Craig Naylor wrote: Your missing my point. We'll start with I don't own one... and I'm playing devil's advocate here... If I did and chose to fly one at an event... what are you going to do grab the controls from me and crash it? Sure you could ask me to leave... so one steps outside the wristband boundary point and flys from there. The side steps are boundless. It's an unenforceable mandate of a mute issue...as a NTSB Administrative Law Judge has actually written judgment against the FAA with prejudice saying the FAA has no jurisdiction over any model airplane issue even if for commercial usage.
http://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q= ... 0277,d.cWc
So... just thinking out loud here...if the NTSB has determined the FAA does not have jurisdiction over model airplanes... what standing do you think they might find for a Sports Car Club over model airplanes?
- Bill Martin
- Posts: 537
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:26 am
- Club: GRA
- Car#: 74
Re: Drones at events
Bottom line is the SCCA dictate is poorly considered and written. Appears they've gotten all caught up in this huge Drone Scare perpetrated by the ignorant media. It's the political correctness of the thing that irritates me. The media doesn't know a drone from a kite.
Scca can require that we don't engage in any activity unnecessary to the event, especially if it has safety connotations. You can't just step outside the wristband area and carry on because you're still on private property and were not admitted for that purpose. And yes...I do realize this is a Devil's Advocate exercise for you. ;)
Scca can require that we don't engage in any activity unnecessary to the event, especially if it has safety connotations. You can't just step outside the wristband area and carry on because you're still on private property and were not admitted for that purpose. And yes...I do realize this is a Devil's Advocate exercise for you. ;)
- Will Kalman
- Posts: 1210
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:24 am
- Club: PSCC
- Car#: 232
Re: Drones at events
DARN IT, I was planning on bringing my drone out to the next event!
- George Schilling
- Club Representative
- Posts: 5135
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:26 am
- Club: CASOC
- Car#: 66
- Location: Lakewood, CA
Re: Drones at events
Bring it anyway Will. We can always "drone" anyone who objects! They won't know what hit 'em! }:)Will Kalman wrote:DARN IT, I was planning on bringing my drone out to the next event!
CASOC Autocross Club, 1984 Van Diemen RF-84, 1600cc Kent, Hewland Mk9, Centerline 2 pc. wheels, Hoosier R25B, SuperTrapp, Zimmer Alloclassic titanium left hip w/Metasul LDH chromium-cobalt lg dia head
- Rick Brown
- Current Solo Director
- Posts: 5117
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:25 am
- Club: PSCC
- Car#: 240
- Location: Lake Elsinore, CA
Re: Drones at events
Lots of extremes here. While I realize Craig was playing devil's advocate regarding getting around the rule, there are also lots of ways to stop you as was pointed out. You are on private property and the facility certainly has the right and authority to kick you out. SCCA's stance seems a little extreme, but I had someone come up to me at the event where one was flown and say that when they were driving that it was a distraction to them. That's all that's required to say no, you can't do that, at least in that way. There certainly could be safe, non-distracting ways of flying one and recording runs. Remember when kids karts first started? There was total paranoia, no car within 5 miles (slight exaggeration) was allowed to be moving. But we learned, adapted and now have them isolated enough when running that cars can be moving in grid.
So maybe an initial ban makes some sense, but there is no reason guidelines could not be developed to allow them in the future.
So maybe an initial ban makes some sense, but there is no reason guidelines could not be developed to allow them in the future.
Since light is faster than sound...many people look bright until they speak...
- George Schilling
- Club Representative
- Posts: 5135
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:26 am
- Club: CASOC
- Car#: 66
- Location: Lakewood, CA
Re: Drones at events
Waaay to much common sense in that statement. In today's litigious society, banning something is the default position lest someone get hurt allowing a litigator to proclaim this should have been foreseen and the perpetrators deserve severe monetary punishment. It's the unfortunate sign of the times. Measured risk.......no longer allowed!Rick Brown wrote:Lots of extremes here. While I realize Craig was playing devil's advocate regarding getting around the rule, there are also lots of ways to stop you as was pointed out. You are on private property and the facility certainly has the right and authority to kick you out. SCCA's stance seems a little extreme, but I had someone come up to me at the event where one was flown and say that when they were driving that it was a distraction to them. That's all that's required to say no, you can't do that, at least in that way. There certainly could be safe, non-distracting ways of flying one and recording runs. Remember when kids karts first started? There was total paranoia, no car within 5 miles (slight exaggeration) was allowed to be moving. But we learned, adapted and now have them isolated enough when running that cars can be moving in grid.
So maybe an initial ban makes some sense, but there is no reason guidelines could not be developed to allow them in the future.
CASOC Autocross Club, 1984 Van Diemen RF-84, 1600cc Kent, Hewland Mk9, Centerline 2 pc. wheels, Hoosier R25B, SuperTrapp, Zimmer Alloclassic titanium left hip w/Metasul LDH chromium-cobalt lg dia head
- KJ Christopher
- Executive Board Member
- Posts: 2818
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:29 am
- Club: No$
- Car#: 11
- Location: Redondo Beach, CA
Re: Drones at events
FTFYBill Martin wrote:Bottom line is the SCCA dictate is poorly considered and written. Appears they've gotten a letter from their insurance carrier specifically stating that there is no coverage if an unmanned aircraft system causes any damage at an event.
kj
Use the email link. I don't read nor get notified of PMs.
Former No$ Club Rep | Former SCCA Area 11 Director |Former CSCC Solo Chair
Caged Z Motorsports - automotive consultation
The ACME Special Now with Super Speed Vitamins
Use the email link. I don't read nor get notified of PMs.
Former No$ Club Rep | Former SCCA Area 11 Director |Former CSCC Solo Chair
Caged Z Motorsports - automotive consultation
The ACME Special Now with Super Speed Vitamins
Re: Drones at events
[
Waaay to much common sense in that statement. In today's litigious society, banning something is the default position lest someone get hurt allowing a litigator to proclaim this should have been foreseen and the perpetrators deserve severe monetary punishment. It's the unfortunate sign of the times. Measured risk.......no longer allowed! [/quote]
George - I agree 100% with you on your statement. I am surprised I don't have to wear a hard hat on the golf course to "save" me from errant golf balls
Waaay to much common sense in that statement. In today's litigious society, banning something is the default position lest someone get hurt allowing a litigator to proclaim this should have been foreseen and the perpetrators deserve severe monetary punishment. It's the unfortunate sign of the times. Measured risk.......no longer allowed! [/quote]
George - I agree 100% with you on your statement. I am surprised I don't have to wear a hard hat on the golf course to "save" me from errant golf balls
- Will Kalman
- Posts: 1210
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:24 am
- Club: PSCC
- Car#: 232
Re: Drones at events
What do the FAA and the SCCA care if I play my bagpipes at an event?
-
- Posts: 60
- Joined: Wed May 21, 2014 12:15 pm
Re: Drones at events
Minion with vidcams would a far better choice. It might be fun running over a minion. Not sure about a UAV.
- Rick Brown
- Current Solo Director
- Posts: 5117
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:25 am
- Club: PSCC
- Car#: 240
- Location: Lake Elsinore, CA
Re: Drones at events
Being of Scottish descent, I wouldn't mind, but others may find the "music" to be distracting, thus a safety hazard.Will Kalman wrote:What do the FAA and the SCCA care if I play my bagpipes at an event?
Since light is faster than sound...many people look bright until they speak...