Anyone with experience using QA1 Springs
Moderator: Mike Simanyi
-
- Posts: 9
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:27 am
Anyone with experience using QA1 Springs
Summit racing has QA1 springs at half the cost of Eibachs. More expensive doesn't always mean more quality and vice-versa. Anyone use these springs and if so did you check actual spring rates before installing?
Thanks for responding.
Tom
Thanks for responding.
Tom
- Mako Koiwai
- Posts: 6490
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:25 am
- Club: SCNAX
- Car#: 34
- Location: South Pasadena, CA
- Contact:
Re: Anyone with experience using QA1 Springs
Some of the low cost items coming out of China use really cheap steel. I remember Chad's first coilovers settling something like almost an inch in the first week! And bolts rounding off on the first day, etc ....
-
- Posts: 3376
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:26 am
- Club: PSCC
- Location: Orange
- Contact:
Re: Anyone with experience using QA1 Springs
You get what you pay for and unless you're starting a low-budget NASCAR team you won't need more than one set. :ibrightdea:Tom Berube wrote:Summit racing has QA1 springs at half the cost of Eibachs. More expensive doesn't always mean more quality and vice-versa. Anyone use these springs and if so did you check actual spring rates before installing?
Thanks for responding.
Tom
-
- Posts: 9
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:27 am
Re: Anyone with experience using QA1 Springs
Thanks for the reply and true, most times you get what you pay for. Unfortunately, as companies try to stay competitive, they end up using the same factories in China, using the same materials. Guess I'll have to research Eibach's quality control a little more. Too bad no one in the club has a spring tester to measure spring rates (new and as you mentioned, settling "X" inches) and has done some independent testing.
- Mako Koiwai
- Posts: 6490
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:25 am
- Club: SCNAX
- Car#: 34
- Location: South Pasadena, CA
- Contact:
Re: Anyone with experience using QA1 Springs
Springs aren't that expensive are they? Maybe not worth experimenting. Maybe the experiment would be too expensive. Just stick with the better ones. German Steel!
The japanese product engineer for Tein USA told me that even in Japan, the rabid, spare no expenses Gymkhana racers ($100K cars!) prefer the regular Tein Springs to the Tein racing springs ... so you're right ... sometimes more is not better?
The japanese product engineer for Tein USA told me that even in Japan, the rabid, spare no expenses Gymkhana racers ($100K cars!) prefer the regular Tein Springs to the Tein racing springs ... so you're right ... sometimes more is not better?
- Mako Koiwai
- Posts: 6490
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:25 am
- Club: SCNAX
- Car#: 34
- Location: South Pasadena, CA
- Contact:
Re: Anyone with experience using QA1 Springs
For what type of car? Some of us have lots of springs that we don't need anymore. I was selling (barely) used Tein 75 mm springs for I believe $25 a set. Also check on your cars enthusiast message boards.
- John Coffey
- Posts: 635
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:24 am
- Club: PSCC
- Car#: 250
- Location: La Habra, CA
- Contact:
Re: Anyone with experience using QA1 Springs
Typical spring steels are Chrome Silicon and Chrome Vanadium. Their chemical compositions are:
CHROME SILICON
0.51-0.59 C
0.60-0.80 Mn
0.035 P
0.040 S
1.20-1.60 Si
0.60-0.80 Cr
CHROME VANADIUM
0.48-0.53 C
0.70-0.90 Mn
0.040 P
0.040 S
0.15-0.35 Si
0.80-1.10 Cr
0.15 V
Most quality steel springs are made with either of these two materials and the most expensive steel springs are made with Chrome Vanadium. It has the highest fatigue resistance and strongest memory of any steel spring wire. Chrome Vanadium is also at least twice as expensive and Chrome Silicon.
Cheaper springs are made with HDMB and OTMB steels and the cheapest springs use 4130, 1095, 1070, and 1050. Junk springs use heat treated 1040, 1030, and 1020.
CHROME SILICON
0.51-0.59 C
0.60-0.80 Mn
0.035 P
0.040 S
1.20-1.60 Si
0.60-0.80 Cr
CHROME VANADIUM
0.48-0.53 C
0.70-0.90 Mn
0.040 P
0.040 S
0.15-0.35 Si
0.80-1.10 Cr
0.15 V
Most quality steel springs are made with either of these two materials and the most expensive steel springs are made with Chrome Vanadium. It has the highest fatigue resistance and strongest memory of any steel spring wire. Chrome Vanadium is also at least twice as expensive and Chrome Silicon.
Cheaper springs are made with HDMB and OTMB steels and the cheapest springs use 4130, 1095, 1070, and 1050. Junk springs use heat treated 1040, 1030, and 1020.
-
- Posts: 3376
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:26 am
- Club: PSCC
- Location: Orange
- Contact:
Re: Anyone with experience using QA1 Springs
Eibachs are made in China?Tom Berube wrote:Thanks for the reply and true, most times you get what you pay for. Unfortunately, as companies try to stay competitive, they end up using the same factories in China, using the same materials. Guess I'll have to research Eibach's quality control a little more. Too bad no one in the club has a spring tester to measure spring rates (new and as you mentioned, settling "X" inches) and has done some independent testing.
- Mako Koiwai
- Posts: 6490
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:25 am
- Club: SCNAX
- Car#: 34
- Location: South Pasadena, CA
- Contact:
- Robert Puertas
- Posts: 1093
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:26 am
- Club: PSCC
- Car#: 44
Re: Anyone with experience using QA1 Springs
The general consensus of people that race for a living is that Hypercoil makes the best springs.
- Will Kalman
- Posts: 1210
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:24 am
- Club: PSCC
- Car#: 232
Re: Anyone with experience using QA1 Springs
Interesting, that's totally counter to my experience. I ordered a set and they rubbed on the threads of my strut body. I called Hypercoils and they said that they had a spec of X inches of vertical devation for each Y inch of spring free-length. They offered to go to their warehouse and hand pick me a set of the straightest springs they could find. Those rubbed, too.Robert Puertas wrote:The general consensus of people that race for a living is that Hypercoil makes the best springs.
I called Eibach and asked them what their square-ness spec was. "Straight" was the answer. So, I asked, "Sure, straight. But really, what's the actual tolerance?" "Straight" was the answer again. OoooK..... So I ordered a set from a local dealer (no hand-picked specials here) and sure enough, they were dead straight and I had no rubbing issues with them.
-
- Posts: 3376
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:26 am
- Club: PSCC
- Location: Orange
- Contact:
Re: Anyone with experience using QA1 Springs
I doubt Eibach would take their mult-million Euro machines and run crappy steel through them. Hypercoil and Swift are both top brands.Mako Koiwai wrote:Unclear as to where there steel comes from:
http://eibach.com/cgi-bin/htmlos.exe/00 ... 4700009976
-
- Posts: 2663
- Joined: Wed May 14, 2008 4:22 pm
- Club: CASOC
- Car#: 32
- Location: HB, CA
Re: Anyone with experience using QA1 Springs
Hypercoils ARE supposed to be very good. I've certainly never had any trouble with them, used'm on multiple vehicles. Randy is right, they do have a very good rep in the big racing community.Will Kalman wrote:Interesting, that's totally counter to my experience. I ordered a set and they rubbed on the threads of my strut body. I called Hypercoils and they said that they had a spec of X inches of vertical devation for each Y inch of spring free-length. They offered to go to their warehouse and hand pick me a set of the straightest springs they could find. Those rubbed, too.Robert Puertas wrote:The general consensus of people that race for a living is that Hypercoil makes the best springs.
I called Eibach and asked them what their square-ness spec was. "Straight" was the answer. So, I asked, "Sure, straight. But really, what's the actual tolerance?" "Straight" was the answer again. OoooK..... So I ordered a set from a local dealer (no hand-picked specials here) and sure enough, they were dead straight and I had no rubbing issues with them.
Not saying you didn't have trubs. Also never had any trouble with eibachs either, got'm on the supra. Probably 3 or 4 sets in the garage.
-
- Posts: 9
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:27 am
Re: Anyone with experience using QA1 Springs
So the answer to my question (although all the other discussions were interesting and valuable) is no one has experience with QA1 springs. Well, I don't want to be the guinea pig so I'll stick with the Eibachs for now.
Thanks for the feedback.
Thanks for the feedback.
- John Coffey
- Posts: 635
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:24 am
- Club: PSCC
- Car#: 250
- Location: La Habra, CA
- Contact:
Re: Anyone with experience using QA1 Springs
FYI... this is the company that actually makes the springs for Hyperco: http://www.mw-ind.com/MatthewWarren/" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false; Hyperco and Hypercoils are a division and a brand name for Matthew Warren Industries. Eibach won some US OEM manufacturing contracts a few years ago and has spring winding facilities here in the US. A lot of their supposed European made springs are actually wound here: http://www.eibach.de/oem/en/index.html" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
A lot more goes into springs then just material. If the spring is pressed to the correct free height too quickly the spring will bow. If the ends are ground at the same times its hard to ensure square. So, even springs made out of the best materials can have structural problems from the manufacturing process.
A lot more goes into springs then just material. If the spring is pressed to the correct free height too quickly the spring will bow. If the ends are ground at the same times its hard to ensure square. So, even springs made out of the best materials can have structural problems from the manufacturing process.
- Steve Ekstrand
- Solo Safety Steward
- Posts: 7482
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:26 am
- Club: CASOC
- Car#: 15
- Location: This space left intentionally blank
- Contact:
Re: Anyone with experience using QA1 Springs
I'd did use a set of QA1's briefly on the Neon. Maybe not the most glowing endorsement (yeah it was the springs that made that car suck....).
Eibach's were backed ordered in the part number I wanted, so I went with the QA1's after checking with my roundy round friends.
QA1's are made in the USA. Same company makes pretty decent rod ends and also owns Carrera shocks. The are popular in four link drag racing apps and you see them used on American muscle cars.
They rolled true and were square. Seemed fine compared to my Eibach, Hypercoil, and KW springs.
Eibach's were backed ordered in the part number I wanted, so I went with the QA1's after checking with my roundy round friends.
QA1's are made in the USA. Same company makes pretty decent rod ends and also owns Carrera shocks. The are popular in four link drag racing apps and you see them used on American muscle cars.
They rolled true and were square. Seemed fine compared to my Eibach, Hypercoil, and KW springs.
Dr. Conemangler
aka The Malefic One
2015 Wildcat Honda F600
aka The Malefic One
2015 Wildcat Honda F600
- Bill Martin
- Posts: 537
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2008 11:26 am
- Club: GRA
- Car#: 74
Re: Anyone with experience using QA1 Springs
I use QA-1s and Eibachs. No problems with either. Don't know how accurate their ratings, but none have ever settled as far as I know. QA-1 advantage is price...Eibach advantage is selection. They offer far more combinations of rate and length. You should use bumpstops to prevent solid stacking of any spring unless specifically designed for it. Like tender springs.
Bigger factor in spring selection is single stage vs two-stage springs. High rate springs don't compress much, so can't extend much before unloading. Hence tender or dual springs to take up the slack. (Note, I'm not talking about progressive springs here...two separate springs at each corner)
-- Bill
Bigger factor in spring selection is single stage vs two-stage springs. High rate springs don't compress much, so can't extend much before unloading. Hence tender or dual springs to take up the slack. (Note, I'm not talking about progressive springs here...two separate springs at each corner)
-- Bill